Browsing this site requires consent to the privacy policy. By continuing to browse, you agree to our privacy policy. If you do not agree, please stop browsing. Privacy policy

All our articles is independent of any advertiser or commercial initiative, and if you buy something through our posts, we may get a small share of the sale. Click here for more information.

Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB vs Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB: Full Comparison!

Created date: 2018-09-30 22:03:28, Updated date: 2020-04-16 18:37:44

Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Are you having trouble comparing the differences in features and performance of the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", or unsure about their differences in ease-of-use, and wondering which to buy? We did a deep-dive comparison of the features, specs, and capabilities of these two smartphone, and provided our rating of which one was a better buy.

Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB

Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

General rating:
Holding comfortrating-image2.4
47/100
rating-image3.0
60/100
Weightrating-image2.4
48/100
rating-image3.5
69/100
Screen sizerating-image4.5
90/100
rating-image4.1
82/100
Display qualityrating-image3.6
71/100
rating-image2.7
53/100
Battery liferating-image4.2
83/100
rating-image3.3
66/100
Processing powerrating-image4.5
89/100
rating-image4.0
79/100
Memory capacityrating-image3.5
70/100
rating-image3.5
70/100
Storage capacityrating-image4.5
90/100
rating-image3.4
67/100
Rear camera performancerating-image3.0
59/100
rating-image3.1
61/100
Front camera performancerating-image2.5
50/100
rating-image3.8
75/100

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", performance comparison

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" size comparison. Which to choose?

The size of the body has a big influence on the ease of carrying and one-handed operation. The narrower the width, the easier it is to firmly grasp and hold, but you also have to take into account the device's thickness. Also, if the width and height are smaller, its easier to operate one-handed since its easier to extend your fingers. On the contrary, if the width and height are large, it's difficult to fit in your pocket and is bulky even when put in a bag, and portability is impaired.

The "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has a width of 88.7mm, a length of 174.1mm, and a thickness of 7.6mm. Also, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a width of 76.2mm, a length of 153.0mm, and a thickness of 7.7mm.

Comparing the width and thickness of the body, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is considerably smaller and more compact than the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB". The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" excels over the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" in terms of being easier to hold with one hand and is therefore less likely to be accidentally dropped. If you're looking for a smart phone with superior grip and hand fit, we recommend purchasing the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" over the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB".

Comparing the width and thickness of the body, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is a more compact size than the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB". For that reason the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has higher one-handed operability, and has greater portability, being less likely to get in the way when being carried. For these reasons, we recommend the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

Comparing the overall size of the two devices, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is a considerably larger size than the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB". In terms of being more convenient to use one-handed, and less likely to get in the way when you're not using it, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is superior to the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB". If you're going for the smart phone sized to be easiest to carry and handle with one hand, we recommend buying the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" over the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB".

ScoreDimensions (width x height x thickness)
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB47/10088.7mm x 174.1mm x 7.6mm
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB60/10076.2mm x 153.0mm x 7.7mm

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", which is more comfortable to hold? Weight comparison

The weight of the device affects hand fatigue and the burden placed upon the wrist. The lighter it is, the longer you'll be able to operate the device without tiring. Also, if the burden placed on the wrist is lower, you'll be able to use the device more comfortably. However if the weight isn't right for you, it could place more of a burden on your body, causing you to feel stress.

The weight of the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is about 211.0g, and the weight of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is about 153.0g. Comparing the weight of the two devices, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is a considerably lighter smart phone than the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB", and there is a difference of about 58g. In terms of the burden placed upon your fingers and wrist, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is superior to the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB". If you are going for a smart phone that won't lead to hand fatigue even after extended use, and is less likely to place a burden on your fingers, we recommend purchasing the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" over the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB".

ScoreWeight
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB48/100211.0g
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB69/100153.0g

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", whose display is easier to use?

The size of the screen affects usability and screen visibility. A larger screen means larger letters and buttons on apps, so the user is less likely to tap adjacent buttons by mistake. In addition, the user can enjoy a more intense experience when playing games and watching videos.

The "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has a 6.44inch display. Also, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a 5.5inch display. Comparing the screen size, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has a larger screen compared to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", with a roughly 0.94inch difference. As a result, the user is less likely to mistap when using apps on the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" than on the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", and is also able to enjoy videos and games on a larger screen. Therefore, we recommend the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB".

ScoreDisplay size
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB90/1006.44inch
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB82/1005.5inch

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", which has a clearer display?

Pixel density affects picture quality, and the higher the pixel density, the better the picture quality, which means the user can gain more enjoyment from games and videos. In addition, higher picture quality decreases eyestrain, which means that the user will experience less eye fatigue after prolonged use.

The resolution on the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is 1080 x 1920, and pixel density is 342ppi. Also, the resolution on the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is 720 x 1280, and pixel density is 267ppi. Comparing the pixel count, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has much higher pixel density than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", with a difference of roughly 75ppi. In terms of having better picture quality and exerting less strain on the eyes, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is superior to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". If you are looking for a smartphone that is easy on the eyes, displaying texts and pictures clearly without any blurring, we recommend the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" over the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

ScorePixel density
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB71/100342ppi
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB53/100267ppi

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", a summary of the differences in battery life

Battery performance greatly affects battery life, but greater battery capacity does not necessarily mean greater battery life, since battery efficiency should also be considered. Bigger screens and higher CPU performance will mean the batteries are depleted more quickly.

The "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is 5300.0mAh, and the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is 3080.0mAh. Regarding battery capacity, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has greater battery capacity than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", with a 2220mAh difference. Since the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" can be used for longer periods without recharging than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", it is great for outdoor use. If you want a smartphone with a longer battery life, we recommend the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" over the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

ScoreBattery capacity
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB83/1005300.0mAh
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB66/1003080.0mAh

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", which has better CPU?

CPU performance affects the ability to process programs, and the ability to process programs is determined by the product of the number of cores in the CPU and the CPU frequency. The higher this performance is, the more smoothly apps and games will run, and with low performance apps and games become heavy and stress is experienced.

The "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB"'s CPU is a Qualcomm MSM8953 Snapdragon 625, with performance measured at 2.0GHz×8(8.0-cores). Also, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"'s CPU is a Qualcomm MSM8940 Snapdragon 435, with performance measured at 1.4GHz×8(8.0-cores). Comparing CPU performance, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has considerably higher specs than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". In terms of being able to comfortably play games and run apps smoothly, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is superior to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". If you're going for a high spec smart phone that runs smoothly and comfortably handles games, we recommend purchasing the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" over the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

ScoreCPU specs
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB89/1002.0GHz×8(8.0-cores)
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB79/1001.4GHz×8(8.0-cores)

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", what's the difference in memory capacity?

RAM affects multitasking ability and the stability of apps. The larger the amount of RAM is, the more stability there will be even in situations where multiple apps are running simultaneously, allowing for comfortable use. In addition, animation will be more smooth, and apps will be less likely to freeze or crash. Also, without sufficient RAM, there are games you won't be able to run, so it is necessary to be careful.

The weight of the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is 4.0GB and the weight of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is 4.0GB. Comparing the devices in terms of RAM, there is almost no difference in the amount of RAM of the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". For that reason they have about the same level of multitasking performance and 3D game and VR smoothness. That's why it is better to make a comparison in terms of other aspects of performance and functionality.

ScoreRAM size
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB70/1004.0GB
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB70/1004.0GB

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", which has more data storage?

Storage capacity affects the amount of data that is capable of being stored. The larger the storage capacity, the more pictures you can take and the more applications you can install. In addition, if your smartphone accepts SD cards, then you can increase its storage capacity. However, there are performance related drawbacks, including a slower data transfer rate than the primary memory, and you cannot transfer all your data on the card, so be warned.

The data storage capacity of the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is 128.0GB. Also the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is 64.0GB. Regarding storage capacity, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has a much larger data storage capacity compared to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", with a roughly 64GB difference. In terms of the number of pictures you can save and the applications that you can install, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" is superior to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". If you are looking for a smartphone that can save more data, we recommend the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" over the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

ScoreStorage size
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB90/100128.0GB
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB67/10064.0GB

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rear camera performance comparison. Which has a higher resolution?

One factor that determines the performance of the exterior camera located on the back of the device (the rear/back camera) is the pixel count. The larger the pixel count, the higher the resolution of the pictures you can take, and the cleaner the pictures will look when printed.

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has a 12.0MP main camera. Also, "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a 13.0MP main camera. Comparing rear camera performance, the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" have approximately the same pixel count. As a result, they can both take pictures and shoot videos of roughly the same quality. Therefore, we recommend comparing the two based on other aspects of performance and functionality.

ScoreRear-camera resolution
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB59/10012.0MP
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB61/10013.0MP

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", whose front camera has a better picture quality?

One factor that determines the performance of the exterior camera located on the front of the device (the in/front camera) is the pixel count. The larger the pixel count, the higher the resolution of the pictures you can take, and the cleaner the pictures will look when printed.

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" has an 5.0MP front camera and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has an 16.0MP front camera. Comparing rear camera performance, the front camera of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a much higher pixel count compared to the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB", with a roughly 11MP difference. As a result, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is more suited than the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" for shooting videos and taking pictures. If you are looking for a smartphone that is suited for shooting high resolution selfies which will look clean when printed, we recommend the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" over the "Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB".

ScoreFront-camera resolution
Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB50/1005.0MP
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB75/10016.0MP

"Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", performance comparison by specification sheet

Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
ImageXiaomi Mi Max 2 128GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
MakerXiaomiXiaomi
Release date2017-062017-11
ColorGold/Matte BlackGold/Dark Grey/Silver/Rose Gold
OSAndroidAndroid
Dimensions (width x height x thickness)88.7mm x 174.1mm x 7.6mm76.2mm x 153.0mm x 7.7mm
Weight211.0g153.0g
Display size6.44inch5.5inch
Display typeIPS LCDIPS LCD
Screen resolution (width x height)1080 x 1920720 x 1280
Pixel density342ppi267ppi
Battery capacity5300.0mAh3080.0mAh
ChipsetQualcomm MSM8953 Snapdragon 625Qualcomm MSM8940 Snapdragon 435
CPU specs2.0GHz×8(8.0-cores)1.4GHz×8(8.0-cores)
RAM size4.0GB4.0GB
Storage size128.0GB64.0GB
Rear-camera resolution12.0MP13.0MP
Front-camera resolution5.0MP16.0MP

Look at a smartphone

Compare smartphones

Look at a smartphone

Compare smartphones

Check price

Articles related to Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB
Articles related to Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB

Search for smartphone with similar ratings as Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB

Articles related to Xiaomi Mi Max 2 128GB
Articles related to Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Search for smartphone with similar ratings as Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

New articles