Browsing this site requires consent to the privacy policy. By continuing to browse, you agree to our privacy policy. If you do not agree, please stop browsing. Privacy policy

All our articles is independent of any advertiser or commercial initiative, and if you buy something through our posts, we may get a small share of the sale. Click here for more information.

Alcatel Idol 2 16GB vs Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Created date: 2018-09-30 23:12:27, Updated date: 2020-04-16 20:24:27

alcatel Idol 2 16GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
alcatel Idol 2 16GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Are you having trouble comparing the differences in features and performance of the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", or unsure about their differences in ease-of-use, and wondering which to buy? We did a deep-dive comparison of the features, specs, and capabilities of these two smartphone, and provided our rating of which one was a better buy.

alcatel Idol 2 16GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
alcatel Idol 2 16GB

Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

General rating:
Portabilityrating-image3.6
70.0mm x 136.0mm x 7.3mm
rating-image3.0
76.2mm x 153.0mm x 7.7mm
Weightrating-image4.0
128.0g
rating-image3.5
153.0g
Size of screenrating-image3.7
5.0inch
rating-image4.1
5.5inch
Screen clarityrating-image1.8
220ppi
rating-image2.7
267ppi
Battery durationrating-image2.5
2000.0mAh
rating-image3.3
3080.0mAh
Processing capabilityrating-image1
1.3GHz×4(4.0-cores)
rating-image4.0
1.4GHz×8(8.0-cores)
Memory capacityrating-image1.0
1.0GB
rating-image3.5
4.0GB
Storage capacityrating-image2.5
16.0GB
rating-image3.4
64.0GB
Rear camera functionrating-image2.5
8.0MP
rating-image3.1
13.0MP
Front camera functionrating-image1
2.0MP
rating-image3.8
16.0MP

Compare Performance and Usability

Size comparison of "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". Which one would you choose?

Your device's size has a huge influence on how easy it is to hold or to operate with one hand. The smaller your device's width, the easier it will be to hold, but you'll also need to take device thickness into account. And when the length and width are both smaller, you'll find that it's much easier for you to operate it one-handed, since your fingers will find it much easier to reach where you want them to. On the other hand, longer lengths and wider widths might lead to devices that are hard to carry in your pocket, bulky even when you keep them in your bag, and all around less portable.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is 70.0mm wide, 136.0mm tall, and 7.3mm thick. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is 76.2mm tall, 153.0mm wide, and 7.7mm thick.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is also more compact than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" in terms of the thickness of the devices. The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is easier than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" to hold with one hand, and you are less likely to accidentally drop it. If you're looking for a smartphone that fits nicely in your hand and can be gripped firmly, we recommend buying the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" rather than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

Comparing the width and height of the devices, the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is more compact than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is easier to carry around than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" and easier to use with one hand. For a smartphone that is comfortable and easy to operate with one hand, and can fit neatly in your pocket or bag, we recommend that you buy the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" rather than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

Comparing the overall sizes, the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is significantly smaller than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is more convenient than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" to use with one hand, and it is less likely to get in your way when not using it. If you prefer a smartphone that is easy to carry around and easy to use with one hand, we recommend that you buy the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" rather than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB".

ScoreDimensions (width x height x thickness)
alcatel Idol 2 16GB72/10070.0mm x 136.0mm x 7.3mm
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB60/10076.2mm x 153.0mm x 7.7mm

Which one is easier to hold, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"? Compare weight

The device weight will effect how quickly you tire from holding it, and how much stress is put on your wrist. The lighter it is, the longer you can hold it without feeling tired. Also, less stress on your wrist will make using it easier and more pleasant. Unless the weight is right for you, it might put too much strain on your body and make using it more stressful.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" weighs 128.0g. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" clocks in at 153.0g. Comparing the weight of the main unit, the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is a lighter phone than the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", with a difference of approximately 25g. Therefore, there is less strain on your fingers and wrists even when you use your phone for a long time on the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" compared to the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". For this reason, the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is recommended.

ScoreWeight
alcatel Idol 2 16GB79/100128.0g
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB69/100153.0g

Which is better in terms of display, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"?

Screen size influences how well you can control your device, as well as how clear the display is. With a large screen, the text and buttons in apps will display large enough so you'll be less likely to accidentally tap the button next to the one you were aiming for. Plus, you'll be able to enjoy more high-impact visuals for games and movies.

The screen size on the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" is 5.0inch, and 5.5inch on the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". Comparing the size of the display and screen, the screen size of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is larger than that of the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of approximately 0.5inch. As a result, there will be unintended touches on the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" compared to the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" and it is possible to enjoy games and videos on a large screen. For this reason, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is recommended.

ScoreDisplay size
alcatel Idol 2 16GB74/1005.0inch
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB82/1005.5inch

Which one has a better display, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"?

Pixel density influences how nice your device's screen looks, with high pixel densities making screens look more beautiful, and letting you get more out of your games and movies. Plus, the nicer you screen looks, the less strain you'll be putting on your eyes, so you'll tend to be able to use your device for longer before your eyes get tired.

The screen on the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has a 540 x 960 resolution and a pixel density of 220ppi. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", on the other hand, has a screen resolution of 720 x 1280 and a pixel density of 267ppi. Comparing the screen definition, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a much higher pixel density than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of about 47ppi. The screen on the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is clear and crisp, and puts less strain on the eyes than that of the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB". If you want to choose a smartphone that is gentle on your eyes with a display that shows text and images clearly, we recommend that you buy the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScorePixel density
alcatel Idol 2 16GB36/100220ppi
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB53/100267ppi

How is the battery duration of "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" different from that of "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" ? See the differences

Battery performance has a big effect on the battery life of your device. However, a high battery capacity doesn't necessarily mean a long battery life. Rather, the rate of power consumption needs to be taken into consideration as well. The larger the screen and the higher the CPU performance, the higher the rate of power consumption on your battery.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has a battery capacity of 2000.0mAh, while the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a 3080.0mAh battery. With regards to battery performance, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a substantially larger battery capacity than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of 1080mAh. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" can be used without charging for a longer time than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", so it can be used when out and about. If you want a smartphone with a longer-lasting battery, we recommend that you buy the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreBattery capacity
alcatel Idol 2 16GB50/1002000.0mAh
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB66/1003080.0mAh

Which is better in terms of CPU function, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"?

Your CPU's speed will influence the processing power of the applications you run, and together with the number of cores in the CPU, as well as its clock frequency, will determine the processing power available for apps. The higher these performance factors, the smoother your games and apps will run. Conversely, if these factors are too low, your apps and games will be sluggish and struggle to run.

The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" uses an Qualcomm MSM8940 Snapdragon 435 CPU that performs at a speed of 1.4GHz×8(8.0-cores). Comparing CPU performance, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has significantly higher specs than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB". The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" proves to be more advanced than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" in the way that apps run quickly and games play smoothly. If you're looking for a high-spec smartphone that runs quickly and plays games smoothly, we recommend that you buy the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreCPU specs
alcatel Idol 2 16GB16/1001.3GHz×4(4.0-cores)
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB79/1001.4GHz×8(8.0-cores)

How is "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" different from "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" in terms of memory capacity?

Your device's multimedia performance and app stability are both influenced by the amount of memory it has available. The more memory, the more apps you can use simultaneously, while keeping everything stable and smooth. Plus, there'll be less chance of animations lagging or apps crashing. You also need to keep in mind that some games won't run at all if there's not enough memory available.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has 1.0GB of memory. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB", on the other hand, has 4.0GB. As for memory performance, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a larger memory capacity than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of about 3GB. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has better multitasking, less crashing, and runs 3D games and VR video better than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB". If you're looking for a smartphone that will remain stable even when you are using multiple apps at the same time, and which will allow you to play 3D games and VR video comfortably, we recommend that you buy the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreRAM size
alcatel Idol 2 16GB20/1001.0GB
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB70/1004.0GB

Which has a better storage capacity, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"?

Storage capacity determines the amount of data you'll be able to save on your device. The more storage you have, the more photos you can take and the more apps you can install. Plus, if your smartphone is compatible with SD cards, then you can increase the amount of available storage. However, SD cards have a slower writespeed, making them less desirable in terms of performance, and users should be aware that it won't be possible to transfer all kinds of data to the card.

The "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has 16.0GB of storage, while the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has 64.0GB. In terms of ROM and data storage, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a much larger capacity than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of about 48GB. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" can save more photos and keep more apps installed than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB". If you're searching for a smartphone that can store more data, we recommended that you buy the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreStorage size
alcatel Idol 2 16GB50/10016.0GB
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB67/10064.0GB

Compare the rear cameras of "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" and "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB". Which one has better picture quality?

One factor in how well your rear camera (the camera on the back of your device) performs is its megapixel count. With a higher megapixel count, you'll be able to take photos with sharper detail, photos that stay clear and sharp even when printed.

The main camera on the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has 8.0MP. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has 13.0MP. The rear-facing camera of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" also has a higher pixel count than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of about 5MP. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is more capable than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" of taking high-definition photos and videos, and produces better results when printing out the photos you have taken. If you want a smartphone that is designed for video and photography, we recommend buying the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreRear-camera resolution
alcatel Idol 2 16GB50/1008.0MP
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB61/10013.0MP

Which has a front camera with better picture quality, "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" or "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"?

One indication of how well your forward facing camera (the camera on the same side as your device's screen) performs is how many megapixels it has. More megapixels means you'll be able to take photos with sharper detail, that still look amazing printed out.

The forward-facing camera on the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB" has a resolution of 2.0MP. The "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB"'s has 16.0MP. The front-facing camera of the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" has a significantly higher number of pixels than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB", with a difference of about 14MP. Therefore, the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" is more suitable for taking photos and videos than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB". If you want to take and print high-quality selfies, we recommend buying the "Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB" rather than the "alcatel Idol 2 16GB".

ScoreFront-camera resolution
alcatel Idol 2 16GB15/1002.0MP
Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB75/10016.0MP

Compare Performance Specs

alcatel Idol 2 16GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
Imagealcatel Idol 2 16GBXiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB
MakeralcatelXiaomi
Release date2014-022017-11
ColorSlate/Chocolate/White/Hot pinkGold/Dark Grey/Silver/Rose Gold
OSAndroidAndroid
Dimensions (width x height x thickness)70.0mm x 136.0mm x 7.3mm76.2mm x 153.0mm x 7.7mm
Weight128.0g153.0g
Display size5.0inch5.5inch
Display typeIPS LCDIPS LCD
Screen resolution (width x height)540 x 960720 x 1280
Pixel density220ppi267ppi
Battery capacity2000.0mAh3080.0mAh
CPU specs1.3GHz×4(4.0-cores)1.4GHz×8(8.0-cores)
RAM size1.0GB4.0GB
Storage size16.0GB64.0GB
Rear-camera resolution8.0MP13.0MP
Front-camera resolution2.0MP16.0MP

Look at a smartphone

Compare smartphones

Look at a smartphone

Compare smartphones

Check price

Articles related to alcatel Idol 2 16GB
Articles related to Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

alcatel Idol 2 16GB

Search for smartphone with similar ratings as alcatel Idol 2 16GB

Articles related to alcatel Idol 2 16GB
Articles related to Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

Search for smartphone with similar ratings as Xiaomi Redmi Y1 (Note 5A) 64GB

New articles